Selling a Rental Property in 2027? Start the Tax Planning Before You List

Selling a rental property can free up cash, simplify your finances, or help fund your next investment. But the amount you receive at closing may look very different from the gain reported on your tax return.

Your purchase price, improvements, depreciation, and unused rental losses all affect the calculation. The timing and structure of the sale can matter, too.

If you’re considering selling in 2027, starting the tax review before listing gives you time to gather records, compare options, and estimate how much cash you’ll keep after taxes.

Start With Your Property’s Tax Basis

Your taxable gain generally depends on the sale proceeds, less eligible selling expenses and your adjusted tax basis.

For a property purchased as a rental, adjusted basis generally starts with the purchase price and certain acquisition costs. Capital improvements increase that amount, while depreciation and other adjustments can reduce it. Expenses already deducted as repairs or maintenance generally cannot also be added to basis.

A roof replacement, addition, or major renovation may therefore matter years after the work was completed. Missing records can make it harder to establish the correct gain.

Tell your CPA whether you inherited the property, received it as a gift, acquired it through a prior exchange, or previously used it as your home. Those circumstances can change the calculation.

Separate Taxable Gain From Cash at Closing

Your mortgage balance affects how much cash you receive, but paying off the loan generally does not reduce your taxable gain.

Consider this simplified example:

  • Original purchase price and eligible acquisition costs: $400,000

  • Capital improvements: $50,000

  • Less accumulated depreciation: ($100,000)

  • Adjusted tax basis: $350,000

  • Selling price: $650,000

  • Less eligible selling expenses: ($40,000)

  • Gain before other tax adjustments: $260,000

If the remaining mortgage is $250,000, cash received before income taxes and other closing adjustments would be approximately $360,000: $650,000 minus $40,000 in selling expenses and the $250,000 loan payoff.

The gain calculation and the cash calculation answer different questions. Both belong in your planning.

Review Depreciation and Suspended Losses

Depreciation often reduces taxable rental income during ownership, but it also reduces the property’s basis. Generally, basis must reflect depreciation allowed or allowable—even if you missed an eligible deduction. Your CPA needs the full depreciation history, including improvements and separately depreciated assets.

The resulting gain may have several tax components. Gain attributable to building depreciation may be subject to a maximum federal rate of 25%, while other portions may be treated differently. Some assets can generate ordinary-income recapture, and the 3.8% net investment income tax may also apply. A single assumed capital-gains rate can therefore produce a misleading estimate. I

Suspended passive losses also deserve attention. These are rental losses you could not deduct in earlier years because of passive-activity limitations.

Generally, selling your entire interest in a passive activity to an unrelated buyer in a fully taxable transaction releases the remaining suspended passive losses. Partial sales, grouped rental activities, installment sales, and exchanges require additional analysis. Don’t assume every loss carryforward becomes deductible just because you sold a property.

For a closer look, read Selling Rental Property? Don’t Overlook Suspended Passive Losses.

Discuss Timing and Structure Before Committing

A useful projection considers the sale alongside your other expected income, deductions, and investment activity. Retirement, a large bonus, stock compensation, or another property sale may change the overall result.

Three situations warrant an early conversation:

  • You previously lived in the property. A home-sale exclusion may apply to part of the gain, depending on ownership and occupancy history. Rental use can limit the exclusion, and gain attributable to depreciation generally cannot be excluded.

  • You intend to buy another investment property. A properly structured Section 1031 exchange may defer eligible gain. Simply selling and reinvesting the proceeds is not enough. Coordinate the exchange before closing; deferred exchanges have strict identification and completion deadlines.

  • You may finance the buyer’s purchase. Installment reporting can change when you recognize eligible gain, but special rules apply to depreciation recapture and suspended losses. Review the terms before agreeing to seller financing.

What to Gather for Your CPA

You don’t need a signed purchase agreement to begin. A reasonable selling-price range and these records can support an initial projection:

  • Purchase and ownership records: Original closing statement, ownership percentages, and any prior exchange, gift, or inheritance documentation.

  • Improvements and depreciation: Major project costs and dates, supporting invoices, depreciation schedules, and any cost-segregation report.

  • Prior tax records: Recent returns, property-specific passive-loss carryforward schedules, and relevant grouping elections.

  • Expected sale details: Estimated price, commissions and closing costs, loan payoff, anticipated closing date, and proposed seller financing.

  • Use history and financial plans: Rental and personal-use dates, expected income for the sale year, and plans for the proceeds.

If our firm already maintains some of these records, we can identify what needs updating rather than asking you to recreate the file.

An initial review should help you understand the estimated tax, cash available after closing, and decisions that still require attention. Update the projection as the contract terms become clearer, and discuss whether you'll need estimated tax payments.

Considering a rental property sale in 2027? Contact Weissgarber CPA before listing to discuss a tax projection and the records needed to evaluate your options.

This article reflects federal tax rules in effect as of November 2026. State and local taxes and individual circumstances may affect the result.

Previous
Previous

Do You Need a Year-End Tax Projection? Five Changes Worth Reviewing Before December 31

Next
Next

Selling Employer Stock Before Year-End: What to Review Beyond the Vest